About Tyler
Proudly serving clients across Indiana.
Tyler was born and raised in Carmel, IN and has lived in central Indiana his whole life. He graduated from Indiana University-Bloomington in 1999 with a Finance degree and has been in the mortgage industry for over 20 years. Tyler has worn many hats and while he has been a branch manager/owner for the past 17 years, his passion is still working directly with customers. His success in both arenas is driven by his unwavering dedication to customer service and overall commitment to excellence.
Tyler takes a more consultative approach with his clients. Every client’s situation is unique. His goal is always to be as transparent as possible. The more informed the client is, the easier it is for them to make the best financial decision for them and their family. He has built a successful team of mortgage bankers with the same set of values. He prides himself in creating an experience that exceeds client expectations, and expects the same of his team.
Since joining AnnieMac Home Mortgage, Tyler has the privilege of co-managing Cartmel Mortgage Group branch with his brother, Travis, and together they have created a family environment where everybody works together helping other families reach their financial goals.
Tyler lives in Fishers with his wife Jessica, and their two children Kinsey and Tucker. In his spare time, he enjoys watching local sports including Pacers, the Colts and IU basketball.
Borrower Testimonials
For my 1st time home buying experience i would give Tyler and Team a 10 out of 10 they made the process seemingly harmless..I am going to recommend them at the highest level to anyone looking to buy a new home .Cobern
The easiest mortgage experience I've ever had. Everyone was great and the closing went smoothly.Jason
Tyler and his team were terrific!Rebecca
Tyler has a wealth of knowledge about the whole process, and always made himself available to explain just about everything. Heather was always on top of keeping clear communication and helped us understand our next steps at every level!Matthew G
The personalization and availability of Tyler made it great!Kyle
As first-time homebuyers, we truly had no idea what we were doing—and we couldn’t have asked for a better guide through the process than Tyler Cartmel at AnnieMac. From the very beginning, Tyler was patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly supportive. He broke everything down in a way that was easy to understand, never made us feel rushed or over...Kristin
- View more testimonials on Experience.com & Zillow.com