Ready to buy your dream home? Start your purchase journey today with competitive rates and expert guidance.
Lower your monthly payments or access your home equity with our refinancing options.
Access calculators, guides, and tools to help you make informed mortgage decisions.
Learn more about our company, explore career opportunities, and discover our impact on the mortgage industry.
Proudly serving clients across Indiana.
Travis began his career over 2 decades ago at Hilliard Lyons and subsequently Merrill Lynch. He helped clients with portfolio reviews and investment research before transitioning into Wealth Management Banking where he specialized in advising clients on securities based loans and home financing. He has since fulfilled a lifelong dream of going into business with his brother, Tyler, as they currently co-manage Cartmel Mortgage Group.
Travis is passionate about homes and personal finance in general and thoroughly enjoys meeting individuals and families from all walks of life. Additionally, he prides himself on helping clients navigate through the loan process and finding the best solution to finance a house and turn it into a home.
Travis was born and raised in Carmel, Indiana and is an alumnus of Butler University where he graduated Magna Cum Laude and Finance with Highest Honors. He lives in Fishers with his wife, Lauren, and their three kids Olivia, Graham and Savannah. He loves spending his spare time with any of his 8 siblings or 17 nephews and nieces. Also, he enjoys playing golf, exercising, trying out new restaurants and going to the movies
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was great to work with! I’ve already recommended him to a friend. He was timely, kind, honest, and answered all of my questions. I work nights too and he worked around my schedule which was very appreciated. Bailee Holler Jun 25
Tyler was great to work with! I’ve already recommended him to a friend. He was timely, kind, honest, and answered all of my questions. I work nights too and he worked around my schedule which was very appreciated.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow I had a great experience. He guided me expertly through the whole process from start to finish. I would recommend him very highly and with no reservations. kmp Jun 25
I had a great experience. He guided me expertly through the whole process from start to finish. I would recommend him very highly and with no reservations.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Travis Cartmel does a great job of communicating all needed information and answering questions. We would use him again, but hopefully we never move. jennifer mroz5 Jun 25
Travis Cartmel does a great job of communicating all needed information and answering questions. We would use him again, but hopefully we never move.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was great to work with from the start. He spent some time with me on the phone giving me all the options I had available and was very punctual. We threw a few curve balls on him and his team by adjusting the closing date and he was very accommodating. zuser201703011614363 Jun 25
Tyler was great to work with from the start. He spent some time with me on the phone giving me all the options I had available and was very punctual. We threw a few curve balls on him and his team by adjusting the closing date and he was very accommodating.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was amazing helping us. We will never use another lender again. He’s our guy! His team has outstanding communication and the are the definition of teamwork. The process was so fast, easy, and pain free. Also who doesn’t like to save a huge chunk of money. Thank you Tyler! The Bensheimer’s askabensheimer Jun 25
Tyler was amazing helping us. We will never use another lender again. He’s our guy! His team has outstanding communication and the are the definition of teamwork. The process was so fast, easy, and pain free. Also who doesn’t like to save a huge chunk of money. Thank you Tyler! The Bensheimer’s
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was very communicative. I had no surprises at closing, and he made the entire process so easy for me. Even with a hiccup on the seller's side, he kept a positive attitude and was very reassuring. Molly Jun 25
Tyler was very communicative. I had no surprises at closing, and he made the entire process so easy for me. Even with a hiccup on the seller's side, he kept a positive attitude and was very reassuring.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Our mortgage experience was incredibly easy and enjoyable. The Cartmel Team helped us understand the process and guided us through everything. Communication was great, we always felt comfortable with the team. They quickly and thoroughly answered any questions we had and were always available when we needed. We highly recommend working with The Car... Dustin Jun 25
Our mortgage experience was incredibly easy and enjoyable. The Cartmel Team helped us understand the process and guided us through everything. Communication was great, we always felt comfortable with the team. They quickly and thoroughly answered any questions we had and were always available when we needed. We highly recommend working with The Car...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler, made the process go by smoothly. Always kept us updated and answered questions right away. Highly recommend! If you want to be stress free throughout the loan process... Tyler is your guy! missnewyork86 Jun 25
Tyler, made the process go by smoothly. Always kept us updated and answered questions right away. Highly recommend! If you want to be stress free throughout the loan process... Tyler is your guy!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler and his coworkers were always very kind and polite. They were there to help and make things easy, especially for a first time buyer like myself. Tyler would take time out of his evenings to help explain things when I didn’t understand. Great guy, great team, great experience. deving Jun 25
Tyler and his coworkers were always very kind and polite. They were there to help and make things easy, especially for a first time buyer like myself. Tyler would take time out of his evenings to help explain things when I didn’t understand. Great guy, great team, great experience.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was tirelessly available when it came to securing a loan for our home! In a time of stress and insecurity he was there to ease our worries and to get every little detail squared away!!! I will be recommending Tyler to everyone I know who needs a mortgage!! zuser201510181927492 Jun 25
Tyler was tirelessly available when it came to securing a loan for our home! In a time of stress and insecurity he was there to ease our worries and to get every little detail squared away!!! I will be recommending Tyler to everyone I know who needs a mortgage!!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler worked extremely hard to make sure i understood everything i needed to do before and after closing. I would recommend Tyler to anyone: friend, family, or associate. Great work Tyler zuser201406082212482 Jun 25
Tyler worked extremely hard to make sure i understood everything i needed to do before and after closing. I would recommend Tyler to anyone: friend, family, or associate. Great work Tyler
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow We worked with Travis and the Cartmel team in buying our first home and we are so glad we did. Travis was professional, kind, and informative. He understands the stress that comes along with being new homeowners and guided us along the way. He is very easy to connect with and he made us feel so welcome when we would meet in his office. He was very ... Kristina Jun 25
We worked with Travis and the Cartmel team in buying our first home and we are so glad we did. Travis was professional, kind, and informative. He understands the stress that comes along with being new homeowners and guided us along the way. He is very easy to connect with and he made us feel so welcome when we would meet in his office. He was very ...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow A friend referred me to Tyler/AnnieMac because of the excellent service she received. I am happy to say I received the same and will also refer others to him. I appreciated the fast and clear communication, ongoing education on the mortgage process and friendliness from everyone on the team. Tia Wise Jun 25
A friend referred me to Tyler/AnnieMac because of the excellent service she received. I am happy to say I received the same and will also refer others to him. I appreciated the fast and clear communication, ongoing education on the mortgage process and friendliness from everyone on the team.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler and Alex were so helpful while buying my first home. They were so knowledgeable and always available every step of the way. I would definitely use them again! user5878903 Jun 25
Tyler and Alex were so helpful while buying my first home. They were so knowledgeable and always available every step of the way. I would definitely use them again!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow I relocated to the Indianapolis area and Tyler took care of the loan for my new house. He was extremely helpful and knowledgeable. He took the extra time to explain to me how things work in Indiana and the options I had. Tyler was always available and was very timely in his responses. I loved working with him!! Sarah Jun 25
I relocated to the Indianapolis area and Tyler took care of the loan for my new house. He was extremely helpful and knowledgeable. He took the extra time to explain to me how things work in Indiana and the options I had. Tyler was always available and was very timely in his responses. I loved working with him!!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler made my husband and I's first home buying experience so simple! He was always available to call and he always had an answer for every question I had. He is honest, has your best interest in mind, and assures you that no question is a dumb one. I LOVED working with him, and absolutely plan to for our future home purchasing needs! taywuest64 Jun 25
Tyler made my husband and I's first home buying experience so simple! He was always available to call and he always had an answer for every question I had. He is honest, has your best interest in mind, and assures you that no question is a dumb one. I LOVED working with him, and absolutely plan to for our future home purchasing needs!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow My husband and I were first time home buyers and we looked at a few lender options, including our bank who we’ve been with forever. We decided to go with the Cartmel team because Tyler was the only lender we spoke with who made our experience feel personal and like he had our best interest at heart. Because of Tyler and his team we could not have... Natalie Spangle Jun 25
My husband and I were first time home buyers and we looked at a few lender options, including our bank who we’ve been with forever. We decided to go with the Cartmel team because Tyler was the only lender we spoke with who made our experience feel personal and like he had our best interest at heart. Because of Tyler and his team we could not have...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow This was my wife and I's first home and their customer service was exception. They answered all of our questions and were there throughout the entire process. We were also on a time crunch to be out of our apartment on time and they closed on the loan in 30 days without ANY delays or setbacks. They know what they are doing and I have already recomm... bspangle1313 Jun 25
This was my wife and I's first home and their customer service was exception. They answered all of our questions and were there throughout the entire process. We were also on a time crunch to be out of our apartment on time and they closed on the loan in 30 days without ANY delays or setbacks. They know what they are doing and I have already recomm...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow The Cartmel Team made my first time home purchasing experience very manageable. They were able to secure and lock a great rate for my loan, and were even present at closing. The Cartmel Team was very knowledgeable, responsive, and provided great communications. Alex Wash Jun 25
The Cartmel Team made my first time home purchasing experience very manageable. They were able to secure and lock a great rate for my loan, and were even present at closing. The Cartmel Team was very knowledgeable, responsive, and provided great communications.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler was GREAT! He took tons of time to explain the homebuying process and the loan application process. I cant say how many times I called and texted with questions, and every time Tyler was willing to help and made sure I understood the process and felt comfortable. B. Nelson Jun 25
Tyler was GREAT! He took tons of time to explain the homebuying process and the loan application process. I cant say how many times I called and texted with questions, and every time Tyler was willing to help and made sure I understood the process and felt comfortable.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler made purchasing my first home incredibly easy and walked me through every step of the process. Home buying can be confusing, but not with Tyler! Cecilia Glickfield Jun 25
Tyler made purchasing my first home incredibly easy and walked me through every step of the process. Home buying can be confusing, but not with Tyler!
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow The Cartmel Team is my "A" Team when it comes to Mortgage assistance. Travis and his team were a blessing to work with. They were very punctual, knowledgeable, and displayed moral intergrity. Travis was there every step all the way to the closing, even with the birth of his daughter 3 days before. To me knowing that I had Travis working behind ... Christopher Owens Jun 25
The Cartmel Team is my "A" Team when it comes to Mortgage assistance. Travis and his team were a blessing to work with. They were very punctual, knowledgeable, and displayed moral intergrity. Travis was there every step all the way to the closing, even with the birth of his daughter 3 days before. To me knowing that I had Travis working behind ...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow Tyler and Alex were on top of everything. When I had questions, they responded quickly and I never felt lost in the process. I appreciate their kindness. It certainly made buying my first home less stressful. Thanks a bunch to the both of you. jacquicb3633 Jun 25
Tyler and Alex were on top of everything. When I had questions, they responded quickly and I never felt lost in the process. I appreciate their kindness. It certainly made buying my first home less stressful. Thanks a bunch to the both of you.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow This was a wonderful experience. I was dreading buying a house and having to go through endless amount of paperwork and signing things I had no idea what they were. The Cartmel team made it a walk in the park!! Everything was explained in easy to understand terms and they made it so easy to go an affordable loan with a GREAT interest rate. I look f... cheathamac Jun 25
This was a wonderful experience. I was dreading buying a house and having to go through endless amount of paperwork and signing things I had no idea what they were. The Cartmel team made it a walk in the park!! Everything was explained in easy to understand terms and they made it so easy to go an affordable loan with a GREAT interest rate. I look f...
Rating: 5.0 out of 5.0 from Zillow My husband and I are first time home buyers and after going through several dud Lenders, we were introduced to the Cartmel team with Annie Mac. We had been working with them from summer 2017 up until our recent purchase here in 2019. They were patient with us and ready to help with any of our concerns. The knowledge, speed, and care they shown for ... jade cheatham Jun 25
My husband and I are first time home buyers and after going through several dud Lenders, we were introduced to the Cartmel team with Annie Mac. We had been working with them from summer 2017 up until our recent purchase here in 2019. They were patient with us and ready to help with any of our concerns. The knowledge, speed, and care they shown for ...